Two certificates for the same compound: reconciling them field by field before trusting either number
Two documents, one compound, and two numbers that appear to disagree. Most of the time they do not: they are answering different questions. This works through the five fields that have to match first, the arithmetic that removes the gaps which are not real, and the one case where no comparison is possible at all.
On this page
A number is not a value until its measurand is named
Two documents arrive for the same compound. One says 99.4%. The other says 98.1%. The purchasing decision looks like a ranking, and the ranking looks obvious. It is not, because neither document has yet said what its number measures.
Reference material documentation is a structured set of claims, not a description of a powder. ISO 33401 exists precisely to sort those claims into mandatory, recommended and optional, so that a user can confirm suitability from the paperwork alone. Reconciliation is therefore a field-by-field exercise: identity first, then the measurand, then the basis, then the assignment, and only then the arithmetic. Done in that order, most apparent disagreements dissolve. Done in reverse, they become disputes.
The five fields that must match before any subtraction
| Field | What it fixes | What goes wrong if it is skipped |
|---|---|---|
| Identity | Which substance, in which form | Two materials are compared as if they were two values of one material |
| Measurand | What the number counts | Two correct numbers are subtracted and the difference is read as quality |
| Basis | As is, dried, anhydrous or free base | A basis shift of about one point is recorded as a purity difference |
| Assignment route | Mass balance, qNMR, titration, chromatographic | A systematic offset between methods is mistaken for a lot-to-lot change |
| Uncertainty and currency | How large a difference may be claimed, and as of when | A difference inside the noise is claimed, or a value describing a state that no longer exists is applied |
Each field can stop the comparison on its own. None of them is a formality.
Identity: the formula weight settles it in one line
A CAS number usually identifies the parent compound. Salts, hydrates and solvates frequently share that number with the free base, so a matching CAS proves that two suppliers are discussing the same molecule and proves nothing about the form they shipped.
The fastest test is subtraction. Take the formula weight on each document and subtract the smaller from the larger. A difference of 36.46 is one equivalent of hydrogen chloride; 18.02 is one equivalent of water. If either appears, the documents do not describe two values of one material, they describe two materials. No reconciliation is required and no substitution decision is available, because the correct operation is a factor, not a comparison.
Take a free base of 300.00 and its hydrochloride at 336.46. The base fraction of the salt is 300.00 divided by 336.46, or 0.8917. A salt certificate reading 99.0% therefore delivers 88.3% of base. Setting that 99.0 against a free-base certificate at 98.5 and concluding that the salt is the better material is an error of roughly ten percentage points in the wrong direction.
The measurand: four quantities that all get called purity
| Reported quantity | What the number actually counts | What it cannot see |
|---|---|---|
| Chromatographic purity, area per cent | The share of integrated peak area belonging to the main peak | Water, residual solvents, inorganic residue, non-chromophoric organics, anything retained on the column |
| Mass-balance content | 100% minus each measured subtractive term | Whatever none of the component assays detected |
| qNMR content | Analyte protons against a calibrant of known purity | Impurities sharing the same chemical shift; water unless suppressed |
| Titration assay | Functional groups that react with the titrant | Everything inert to that reaction, including closely related analogues |
The first two are routinely filed side by side and read as if they disagreed. Take one vial: water 0.15% by Karl Fischer, residue on ignition 0.05%, total chromatographic impurities 0.35%. The chromatographic purity is 100 minus 0.35, or 99.65%. The mass balance is 100 minus 0.35 minus 0.15 minus 0.05, or 99.45%. The gap of 0.20 points is not a discrepancy; it is exactly the two terms the chromatogram never sees.
That arithmetic also works as a diagnostic. When a supplier reports 99.9 area per cent alongside 98.6 mass balance, ask for the subtractive terms. If water, solvents and residue total 1.4%, both numbers are consistent and the material simply carries 1.4% of matter that does not absorb. If the supplier cannot produce that sum, one of the two numbers is being used as a purity claim it was never designed to support.
The basis: the 1.2 points that never existed
Both major pharmacopoeias calculate on an as-is basis unless a monograph states otherwise, and the European leaflet is explicit about it: the assigned content of a reference standard is expressed as is, and a standard dried before use is no longer suitable for its intended purpose. Drying is not a neutral preparation step. It changes the material the number refers to.
Two documents, both internally consistent, both about the same substance:
- Lot A: 98.6% as is, water 1.2%. On the dried basis: 98.6 divided by 98.8, times 100, gives 99.80%.
- Lot B: 99.5% on the dried basis, water 0.8%. As is: 99.5 times 0.992 gives 98.70%.
Read raw, the file shows a 0.9-point gap in favour of B. Reconciled on one basis, the gap is 0.10 points, inside almost any uncertainty either document is likely to carry. The conversion is two lines of arithmetic and it reverses the ranking.
The error also has a direction worth naming. A dried-basis number applied as though it were as is inflates the apparent strength of the standard by the water content, here 1.2%, and that inflation propagates into every result calculated from it. Being a bias rather than a scatter, it is invisible to replicate injections and survives every precision check in the file.
Uncertainty: whether a difference is even permitted to exist
An assigned uncertainty is not the producer's repeatability. ISO 17034 requires the budget behind an assigned value to include, at minimum, the characterization step including any difference between the procedures used, between-unit and within-unit inhomogeneity, and changes during storage and transport. The figure on the certificate is therefore the value at release under the stated storage, with a shelf-life model already folded into its uncertainty. A lot held three years at the wrong temperature has spent part of that budget without changing a character on the document.
Where both documents state an expanded uncertainty at the same coverage factor, the comparison is mechanical. Lot A at 99.4% with 0.4, lot B at 98.9% with 0.3, both at k equals 2. The difference is 0.5 points. The combined expanded uncertainty is the square root of 0.4 squared plus 0.3 squared, which is 0.50 points. The difference equals its own uncertainty to the last digit, so the two documents do not support a statement that the lots differ, whatever the chromatograms look like.
The harder case is a document that declines to state an uncertainty at all. The Ph. Eur. leaflet template is explicit that the uncertainty of the assigned value is not stated because it is considered negligible in relation to the defined limits of the method-specific assays for which the standard is used. That is a defensible statement and it is not a number. It cannot be entered into the square root above.
What survives is a different question. Instead of asking whether two values agree, you ask whether each value falls inside the limit the method must enforce. That is weaker, but it is the only comparison the paperwork supports. Supplying a plausible uncertainty to reach the stronger claim produces a conclusion with a precision the file does not have.
What the document is designed not to contain
Some absences are deliberate, and none of them can be reconciled against anything.
USP does not issue certificates of analysis for its reference standards; it issues USP Certificates, which are stated not to describe completely the results obtained during evaluation. The assigned value appears on the label or the certificate, and a value of 100.0% cannot be assumed for any USP reference standard that does not carry one. Where no assigned value is given, the lot was not developed for quantitative use. An absent number is a statement of scope, not an omission, and setting it against a supplier's 99.2% does not create a comparison, it creates a category error.
The European leaflet carries a comparable boundary in its instructions: the standard is used as is and not dried, and once the container has been opened its entire content must be used immediately, further storage and re-use not being warranted. The state the number describes is a sealed container. Where a file compares a certificate issued years ago with a vial that has since been opened, resealed and stored, the second item may not be the material the document describes, and no arithmetic repairs that.
Decision rules
| Situation | What the documents support | Action |
|---|---|---|
| Identity differs by salt or hydrate | Nothing comparable | Apply the factor, or treat as a different item |
| Same measurand and basis, difference below combined uncertainty | No demonstrable difference | Interchangeable for the stated use; record the comparison |
| Same measurand and basis, difference above combined uncertainty | A real difference | Bridge the lots before switching |
| Different measurands | No substitution decision | Bridge, and state both numbers in the file |
| Uncertainty not stated on one document | Only a limit check | Bridge in every case |
Where the table says bridge, the cheapest design is a ratio rather than a pair of values: both lots at the same nominal concentration, injected alternately in the same run against the same calibration, so that everything common to the two preparations cancels and the comparison no longer depends on either assigned value being correct.
Six questions before the comparison starts
Ask the supplier in writing, and keep the answers with the certificate: what exactly does the reported percentage measure; is it as is, dried, anhydrous or on the free base; if it is a mass balance, what are the individual subtractive terms; what is the expanded uncertainty and at which coverage factor; what is the assignment route and the traceability statement behind it; and what are the storage and handling instructions after opening. Five of the six fall under mandatory or recommended content in ISO 33401. The sixth, the subtractive terms, is the one that lets a reviewer check the arithmetic instead of trusting it.
None of these is answered by a catalogue page, and none requires a laboratory. They decide whether two documents can be compared at all, which is an earlier and different question than which number is higher. The guides below cover reading a single certificate, the uncertainty that follows it into solution, and the conversions that fail when a basis is assumed rather than read.
Reading a certificate of analysis | reference standard or analytical standard | salt and hydrate conversion | uncertainty budget for a standard solution | when the standard is the OOS suspect
Frequently asked
Two certificates for the same compound report different purities. Which one is wrong?
Can a chromatographic purity be compared with a mass-balance content?
How is a dried-basis content converted to an as-is basis?
Is a difference smaller than the combined uncertainty a real difference?
What if one certificate states no uncertainty for its assigned value?
Why does a USP reference standard certificate carry no purity figure?
Sources and further reading
Every document below is published by the body that owns it; none of them is a summary written by us. Accessed 2026-11-18.
- ISO - ISO 33401:2024, Reference materials: contents of certificates, labels and accompanying documentation — that the accompanying documentation is a structured set of information in mandatory, recommended and other categories, intended to let a user confirm the suitability of the material from the paperwork
- ISO - ISO 17034:2016, General requirements for the competence of reference material producers — the requirements a producer is assessed against, including the assignment of property values and the uncertainty contributions that must be considered for a certified value
- ISO - ISO 33407:2024, Guidance for the production of pure organic substance certified reference materials — the specific technical considerations for pure organic substance reference materials, which is the category where content is assigned by mass balance rather than by bioassay
- EDQM - FAQ: are drying conditions required before use — that where no drying conditions are stated the substance is used as received, that an assigned content is expressed as is, and that a standard dried before use is no longer suitable for its intended use
- EDQM - Information leaflet, Ph. Eur. Reference Standard (sucrose CRS batch 2) — the leaflet template statement that the uncertainty of the assigned value is not stated because it is considered negligible against the limits of the method-specific assays, together with use as is, do not dry, and use the entire content once opened
- USP - Reference standard certificates and assigned values, policy statement — that USP issues certificates rather than certificates of analysis, that these do not describe the evaluation results completely, and that 100.0 per cent cannot be assumed where no assigned value is given because the lot was not developed for quantitative use
Send us a CAS number
Availability, documentation and lead time — answered by the people who handle the batch, not a ticket queue.